One embraces chaos and glorifies Turkey’s Islamic past. The other promises the badly divided country a slightly calmer and more prosperous future.
Voters decided to give President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan and his rival Kemal Kılıçdaroğlu another chance Sunday to convince them which of these starkly different alternatives is better.
A close outcome in which neither picked up 50 percent of the vote means the two will face each other again in Turkey’s first presidential runoff on May 28.
Few expect either Turkey’s longest-serving leader or his 74-year-old secular rival to change their stripes in a fortnight.
Erdoğan is the man who rose from a hardscrabble part of İstanbul to become Turkey’s longest-serving leader — a devout 69-year-old who has created chronic headaches for the West and become a hero for Turkey’s working classes.
“Erdoğan is our chief and we are his soldiers,” 48-year-old Sennur Henek told AFP while attending one of the president’s packed campaign rallies.
Kılıçdaroğlu is a bookish former civil servant from a historically repressed Kurdish group who has lost half a dozen national elections to Erdoğan while leading his secular party.
His frank kitchen chats with voters have turned him into a social media star at 74.
Kılıçdaroğlu also promises to retire after stripping the presidency of Erdoğan’s powers and then “go spend time with my grandchildren.”
Many say they are voting for Kılıçdaroğlu for the simple reason that he is not Erdoğan.
‘Keeps his word’ –
Erdoğan’s place in history already rivals that of Ottoman sultans and Mustafa Kemal Atatürk — the revered founder of modern, secular Turkey.
He has overseen economic booms and busts while adhering to an Islamic vision of a great Turkey that is ready to go to war to defend its national interests.
Erdoğan has launched offensives in Syria and jousted incessantly with Greece.
His interventions in Libya and Nagorno-Karabakh swung the outcomes of complex conflicts involving the interests of traditional great powers.
Erdoğan’s courtship of Russia upset Washington — and his sale of weapons to Ukraine irritated the Kremlin.
But he always seemed to know how to play one off the other in order to come across as a statesman before his audience back home.
“This is a person who keeps his word — a man,” Russian President Vladimir Putin said of Erdoğan in 2020.
“If he believes it is advantageous for his country, he goes to the end.”
‘I am not sinful’
Kılıçdaroğlu hopes to swiftly undo what Erdoğan spent more than two decades building.
He would start by moving the presidency out of the 1,100-room marble palace that Erdoğan erected in Ankara and back into the more humble abode used by Atatürk.
“I will bring spring to this land. I will bring serenity,” he once said.
It is a promise that has captivated the youth and a cross-section of Turks exhausted by Erdoğan’s culture wars and polarising rhetoric.
Kılıçdaroğlu also pledges to release many of the popular figures jailed by Erdoğan’s government in the wake of a failed but bloody 2016 coup attempt.
He vows to end Erdoğan’s “one-man regime” and the stigmatization of feminists and the LGBTQ community.
But he is also trying to temper his secular stance by committing himself to inscribe Erdoğan’s removal of headscarf restrictions into Turkish law.
Kılıçdaroğlu’s defining campaign moment came when he tweeted a video in which he broke a Turkish cultural taboo by talking about being Alevi.
The group has been targeted by violent repression because it follows a more spiritual Islamic tradition that separates it from Sunni and Shiite Muslims.
“God gave me my life,” Kılıçdaroğlu said in the video. “I am not sinful.”
‘Devil you know’
Some analysts are portraying the vote in terms as stark as the difference between the two candidates.
“Either Erdoğan will lose, giving Turkey a chance of restoring full democracy, or he will win and likely remain in power for the rest of his life,” Washington Institute senior fellow Soner Çağaptay said.
Others highlight the economic relief that would come were Kilicdaroglu given a chance to tackle Turkey’s dire cost-of-living crisis with orthodox financial prescriptions.
“Policy differences over the economy are the reason why markets will be watching this election closely,” said Hamish Kinnear of the Verisk Maplecroft consultancy.
But veteran Turkey watcher Timothy Ash posed a contrarian question.
“Will voters opt for the ‘devil you know’ in Erdoğan or an untested broad coalition which could easily splinter after elections?” Ash asked.
“And with Erdoğan, they know he will strut his stuff on the international stage, batting for what he, and many of them, will view as Turkish national interests.”